First produced over ten years ago, the Watermill Theatre’s production of Calamity Jane delivers a heartfelt rendition of the beloved 1953 classic Doris Day musical. As the production returns to theatres, it is clear that the film’s original charm has remained timeless.
The original musical was influenced by the legend of the sharp-shooting reputation of the real Calamity Jane of Deadwood, South Dakota. She was an American scout and gunwoman, famous for her vulgar language and decision to wear traditional male clothing. Though the production isn’t historically accurate, at the heart of the musical is the story of a woman who successfully fits into a man’s world. The 2025 Watermill production of Calamity Jane is no exception to the original soul of the play. The central plot uses the myth that there was a potential romance between Calamity and Wild Bill. The two characters begin by antagonising one another, and in conventional storytelling style, this united hatred towards each other transforms into a romance. Though foreseeable, the predictability of the love story didn’t take away from the charm; there was almost something comforting in watching such a simplistic plot.
I had never seen West End performer Carrie Hope Fletcher live before, though I was well aware of her award-winning reputation. After witnessing her captivating portrayal of the titular Calamity, it was clear that every accolade she has received is well deserved. Fletcher delivered each musical number with effortless grace and charisma, fully embodying the role and making it impossible not to believe in her as Calamity.
A standout moment was during the song Secret Love, which Fletcher sang with ease, demonstrating her ability. During this powerful song, the elderly couple I was seated next to reached over to take each other’s hand. This subtle gesture perfectly summed up the emotion filling the auditorium. The chemistry between Fletcher’s Calamity and Vinny Coyle’s Wild Bill Hickok was undeniable. From the moment their playful rivalry hinted at something deeper, I was fully invested in their connection. Through a series of touching and heartfelt interactions, their relationship unfolded naturally, making the eventual romance all the more rewarding.
When this adaptation first debuted, the stage layout required the band to perform onstage. The creators kept this approach on tour, allowing audiences to fully appreciate the actors’ musical talent as they played instruments while seamlessly staying in character.
Matthew Wright’s set and costume design brilliantly transported us from the modern world to the heart of the story. With minimal set changes, the transition from South Dakota to Chicago was seamless. A standout example was the transformation of the piano from the Golden Garter saloon into a cart, complete with wheels and parasols. This simple yet effective design choice, though abstract, clearly guided the plot while adding visual interest.
Calamity Jane is a delightful, feel-good love story, whether you’re familiar with the original film or not. Full of charm and energy, it’s an uplifting, whip-crackin’ adventure that promises fun for everyone.
