The Royal Shakespeare Company is never afraid to take on a big challenge, not even a stage adaptation of ‘the greatest English novel’, but has it bitten off more than it can chew?

The RSC’s adaptation of George Eliot’s Middlemarch runs at the Swan Theatre, Stratford-upon-Avon, until 16 January 2027.
George Eliot’s epic Middlemarch story has been split into two parts for its debut at the Swan Theatre in Stratford-upon-Avon, where it runs during Christmas until January 16, 2027.
Charting life, love, secrets and wrong-doings amid a Warwickshire town in the early 1800s, the backdrop of political reform and medical advances give it more depth than a soap opera in the same vein as a Dickens’ classic.
It’s long, as to be expected, with Part 1 and Part 2 both around three hours. I caught them on the same day, but six hours of action is heavy going and my advice would be to savour each production and split them over two different days. But make sure you see them in order.
Adaptor Nina Raine has cleverly used female author Eliot within the productions as a kind of narrator. Amanda Root is perfectly cast as Eliot, earnest and reliable as she urges characters on and helps explain their inner thoughts through easy conversations.
It’s a deft move that keeps the story bubbling along gently while weaving in intriguing facts about Eliot’s own rebellious life. Raine has added plenty of humour too, but in a light touch that’s in keeping with the much-loved novel.
When it comes to the staging, Middlemarch is set on a wide open, bare stage under the eaves of timber roof beams. Director Jeremy Herrin, who was responsible for the RSC’s acclaimed staging of Wolf Hall and Bring Up The Bodies, makes sure the characters bring the essence of the book to life. Some are caricatures, but all are intriguing.
Accompanying them is an understated piano score, beautiful choral music and plenty of candlelight that keep this traditional production firmly rooted in the Victorian era. Something the Middlemarch purists will be happy about thanks to Grace Smart’s appropriate set and costume designs.
Part 1 opens meaningfully with the full ensemble on stage. After Eliot quotes her passage about how a candle held up to a mirror highlights all its scratches, the cast all light their own wick, and so the story begins into these many lives, their faults, loves and deceptions. Romance is at the centre of the plot as we follow well intentioned heiress Dorothea Brooke and Nia Towle playing her is an enchanting lead.
Women are at the forefront of this extraordinary novel and Dorothea is slightly put in the shade due to outstanding performances from both Emma McDonald and Lizzie Annie. McDonald is comically self-interested and haughty as Rosamond Vincy, who has her sights set on modern thinking doctor Tertius.
While Annis wins over hearts as kindly hard-working Mary Garth and Dorothea’s quirky sister Celia Brooke. Annis, seen recently in TV series Under Salt Marsh has a series of awards and nominations to her name including Most Promising Newcomer at the Critics Circle Theatre Awards, and you can see why as she has a natural rapport on stage.
It’s a strong cast all round. Rory Alexander keeps romantic lead Will Ladislaw brimming with passion, Ebenezer Gyau has a charm as Fred Vincy, making Mary’s love of him understandable while Andrew Richardson turns heads as Tertius moves between optimism and the anguish of impending debt. Best of all is the vivaciousness of John Hodgkinson, who is a joy as both devious Mr Bulstrode and larger than life Borthrop Trumbull. The stage seems brighter every time he is on it.

While Part 1 is a complete story within itself and lays the foundations, it continues on with the same characters and has more revelations, passion and drama in Part 2, which I preferred. There’s also a satisfying romantic finale with passion amid a rainstorm.
Bringing this epic novel to stage is no easy feat but writer Raine and director Herrin have achieved wonders. Middlemarch is masterfully brought to life and its gentle charm, humour and romance can’t help but delight.






